It's Complicated: You Can’t See Everything

Richard Collins

Teisho, Stone Nest Dojo & New Orleans Zen Temple, 1 November 2026

True vision isn’t just seeing seeing. It’s also seeing not seeing. And true understanding isn’t just understanding understanding. It’s also understanding not understanding. If you understand anything, you don’t understand. Only when you understand nothing is it true understanding. Understanding is neither understanding nor not understanding.

– The Zen Teachings of Bodhidharma
(trans. Red Pine)

Yesterday, on Halloween, I went to see the film You Can See Everything. Even though it has gotten a lot of hype, I was one of only four people in the theatre. This is rural Tennessee, after all. But Halloween was a fitting time to see it because the film showcased the masks we wear, the realities we deny, the roles we play, and the delusions that can destroy us if we let them.

It is one of the most “Zen” movies I can think of without being obviously about Zen or Buddhism, as are Jim Jarmusch’s Ghost Dog or Kim Ki-Duk’s Spring, Summer, Fall, Winter... and Spring. What I mean by that is this film enacts the problems of illusion and delusion in a real-life contemporary setting and doesn’t let us off the hook by telling us what to conclude. Even though “you can see everything,” you end up seeing nothing, or rather you don’t know exactly what it is you’re seeing. That is the film’s power.

The Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences is going to have to do some soul-searching, like what the Nobel Academy did when they decided to award Bob Dylan the Nobel Prize for Literature; they are going to have to rethink what a “Best Picture” is.

What if a documentary happens to be the “best collaborative effort of many people, taken together,” which is the vague MPAS definition to qualify for the Oscar for “Best Picture”? No documentary has won “Best Picture” before because they are usually ghettoized in a separate category called “Documentary Feature” and not taken seriously (ironically) as film art.

The Golden Globes is more restrictive, awards going to the “Best Motion Picture – Drama” or, in the acting categories “Best Actor or Actress" for the Oscars and “Best Performance by an Actor or Actress” in the Golden Globes.

But what if the “performance” is not by an actor playing a role but by a “real” person appearing as themselves, as in a documentary film?

The second half of this “documentary” complicates the issue by bringing in Amanda Seyfried, who had already played the character of Elizabeth Holmes in a Hulu TV production called The Dropout. But in the second half of this film, Amanda plays herself reenacting Elizabeth and thus going beyond being interviewed and actually acting. Does she deserve an Oscar as “Best Supporting Actress”? Most of the time she is not “acting,” except to the extent that she may be “acting” even when she is just being herself.

That brings up the main theme of the film, which is to what extent are we ever authentically ourselves, not playing a role, especially in the corporate and film worlds? The key to this theme is a phrase that comes up repeatedly. A New York Times profile on Holmes quoted her — correctly or incorrectly — as saying, “They’re not playing me. They’re playing a character I created.” But what is the difference between “me” and a “character” I create?

No one is exempt from this character-creating persona, even the filmmaker himself, Nathan Fielder, who began shooting as an off-camera presence and was eventually incorporated into the presiding narrator and a main character, along with Elizabeth Holmes and Billy Evans, creating the triangle that all good drama exploits ever since Sophocles introduced with the third actor, the tritagonist, who complements and complicates the relationship of the protagonist (Elizabeth Holmes) and deuteragonist (Billy Evans). It’s a classic structure, not unlike the roles played by Gatsby, Daisy, and Nick Carraway in that classic American narrative about money and success, love and obsession, truth and deceit.

What makes it a Zen movie? It behaves like a koan. You can see everything, but that doesn’t mean you see everything. You don’t see things the way they actually are. You only see them in ways they are presented to you by the media, by advertising, by the legal system, by the movie industry. Above all, you cannot trust the people (characters) themselves, who are all unreliable narrators. They are all created (and curated) for our consumption, either by their mediators, or by themselves. By the end of the film, you have seen a lot, but you have no definitive answer. In that way, though, knowing-not-knowing, perhaps you are a little wiser.

This is not usually the case with a documentary, which is supposed to inform you and come to some resolution about a subject: thesis, development, conclusion. One critic complained that he likes more “truthiness” to his documentaries. We are certainly informed, but we must confront our own unknowing about whether Elizabeth is “authentic” even when she is testifying to her own truth. Her most revealing statement, I think, might be when she is asked if she knew Amanda was going to visit Billy. She says, “I don’t know if I knew.” That seems to apply to a lot of her self-awareness. She seems so confused about her “crime” that she seems to have convinced herself that she doesn’t know what she knew. Or she is stonewalling us all (and herself) with that sanpaku stare.

It’s a long movie, three hours, but it is fascinating from beginning to end. This has a lot to do with the use of stillness and silence. Sustained close-ups encourage us to “read” the faces, especially the eyes of both Elizabeth and Billy with their unblinking wide-eyed, arch-browed challenge to see into their soul (if they have one — and they seem to think that they have one, that they share). Most films discourage us from thinking about a scene by quickly and constantly cutting from one image to another in rapid succession because they are afraid we might get “bored.”

The length also has to do with the use of silence. Ari Balouzian’s score is extremely effective in that it is unobtrusive but conducive to setting the contemplative mood. (Balouzian also composed the score for the recent reality-based film Primetime.) You hardly know there is a score at all until the credits come on. But it provides diacritical marks and punctuation that conduct our emotions and suspense, often with the plucking of a bass like the ticking of a baritone clock or the thumping of our hearts. The resemblance to the Zen-inspired compositions of Philip Glass is striking. There are Glass-like monotonous repetitions sprinkled with bells and haunted by distant drums or an occasional piano riff. Very technologically eerie and surreal but also primal and tribal.

We are reminded that music is really silence punctuated by sound, not the other way around, the most extreme example being Cage’s famous “4’ 33”” that I once saw performed in a concert hall in Bucharest. The Heart Sutra tells us that form is emptiness and emptiness is form (phenomena arises out of emptiness, emptiness arises out of phenomena, but they are the same thing). Emptiness is the profound silence which we sometimes forget in our pursuit of the surface stimulation of sight, sound, and meaning.

Poetry is a blank page punctuated with lines of sound, and scripts (which appear from time to time in the film as a reminder that this is all written) are arranged on a page with lots of white space to separate direction, actor, and speech. Fielder insists that dialogue is really silence punctuated by speaking, which most directors suppress with overbearing sound to drown out any thoughts we might be tempted to have while watching their spectacles, since reflection is likely to reveal how stupid they are.

Ralph Waldo Emerson predicted a long time ago that there would come a time when a clear distinction between fiction and nonfiction genres would be dissolved into “narrative.” There used to be a clearer distinction between fiction and nonfiction, but we have created a new name for an old genre that blurs that easy and inaccurate dichotomy: “creative nonfiction.” Perhaps we should have a film genre called “creative documentary.”

Fielder has certainly blurred the genres creatively — not to confuse us, but to clarify the paradoxes of reality. As Amanda Seyfried concludes with the final speech in the film, “It’s complicated.” Something we rarely have to face in the movie theatre but face every day on the cushion watching the blank wall during zazen.

Taisen Deshimaru, the Modern Daruma, with a portrait of the Ancient Daruma (Bodhidharma)

The Medusa Buddha

At the recent Japan Fest at the New Orleans Museum of Art, we set up our Zen meditation space in one of the galleries, as we have for the past several decades. The galleries change every year, but the practice of zazen remains the same.

This year we placed our zafus along the walls and invited curious visitors to just sit for a while in the silence of their own reflection even as the noise in the museum surrounded them. This is the practice of zazen, sitting upright in the deep calm available in a calamitous world.

In the center of our gallery, high on a rough cypress plinth, sat a sculpture by Louise Bourgeois. It is called Female Portrait, but it is really a Medusa in white marble that anyone might mistake from behind to be a Buddha. And for the duration of the day, she became the central figure of our temporary temple, our Medusa Buddha.

In Buddhist iconography, snakes hold a sacred place. The Naga serpent or dragon was known as a protector, metamorphosing into shelters or set at entrances to ward off unwanted influences or visitors. These might be actual storms (sun and rain) or symbolic storms (delusions, angers).

You can see the sacred serpent in countless representations of the Buddha, depicted either realistically as an actual cobra, Mucilinda, spreading its cape behind the Buddha to protect him from the elements under the bodhi tree, or sometimes abstractly as a flared backdrop like a throne.

Nagarjuna, whose name means Noble Serpent, explored the profound wisdom of emptiness, bringing back these secrets from the underworld of serpents. And so on….

Medusa made the perfect Buddha for us that day, shielding us from the noisy festival outside our gallery temple. Self-sufficient, Medusa needs no outside protectors, her strength comes from within, as in Zen, her self-generating serpents enveloping her body with coils of pure white marble. She is her own Naga, just like a monk in zazen.

Medusa famously turned men into stone with her gaze, but this is only her most popular and simplistic role. She is also an icon of rage at being violated and not just by the gaze of men (or rape by Poseidon), a gaze she returns in spades.

In Louise Bourgeois’ interpretation, though, she seems to have conquered her rage. There is in her buddha-like shape and grounded posture no rage, only a ghostly peace; no writhing, only the stillness of marble purity. Like a perfectly balanced androgynous Buddha.

Abbot Richard Collins speaks to an audience at Japan Fest on 10 October, 2026.

One Year in the Stream

Preston Thomas
(Originally Published
on Substack on 5 July, 2026)

On June 22, 2025, I was ordained as a bodhisattva or lay practitioner in the Soto Zen tradition. I received ordination from Richard Collins, the abbot of the New Orleans Zen Temple (NOZT) and Stone Nest Dojo in Sewanee, Tennessee. Shortly thereafter, I published a reflection on what the ceremony meant to me.

Richard is a teacher in a lineage that comes down from “Homeless” Kodo Sawaki and Taisen Deshimaru, who passed the practice of zazen (meditation) on to various Westerners in Paris, France. One of them was a gruff, American businessman by the name of Robert Livingston. At Deshimaru’s request, Livingston brought the practice to America and opened NOZT in the 1980s. The rest is history (or, at least, a little piece of the history of American Zen).

In my first short stint with NOZT during my teen years, I met Robert. With his bald head and booming, gravelly voice—which sometimes had a hint of a pseudo-Japanese accent—he was a force to be reckoned with, even in his old age.

Last year, I knew I wanted to take the formal step of ordination with Richard, Robert’s successor, after I met him. I had been meditating on my own for years—and had practiced on and off with groups—so it was finally time to commit. When Richard accepted the request, he gave me a list of homework assignments, including readings and memorizing chants. He ended his email by saying, “Welcome to the stream.”

I thought, “Hmm, ‘stream’—that’s a cool image.” But I didn’t really know what it meant—and I do not fully understand it now. In Zen practice as in jiu jitsu, creativity, and life overall, if you think you understand something, you are probably inviting some kind of trouble.

I did not pretend to understand what I was getting myself into when I adopted the bodhisattva vows. Countless books have been written on the subject, such as Shohaku Okumura’s Living by Vow, which I am reading currently. This is how Okumura translates the four vows:

Sentient beings are numberless; I vow to save them.
Desires are inexhaustible; I vow to put an end to them.
The dharmas are boundless; I vow to master them.
The Buddha’s Way is unsurpassable; I vow to attain it.

One could go on forever about what these lines mean. As of last year, all I knew was that I had no other choice but to give myself wholeheartedly to meditation practice. I had tried to make worldly success my chief aim, and I had even tried to make spiritual or meditative practice subordinate to that aim. I had tried out various flavors of Zen, and I really appreciated the unorthodox, punk rock flavor that I found at Angel City Zen Center in Los Angeles—shoutout to my friends at ACZC.

While practicing at Angel City and elsewhere, I viewed meditation as something that could help me survive the grind of daily life—in particular, the filmmaking hustle in Los Angeles. I viewed meditation as a type of mental health crutch, but I was not ready to commit to it—to give myself over to it completely. In past posts, I have detailed how I reached that point—on a personal and psychological level—so I will not rehash that narrative here.

How has ordination—committing to the vows—impacted my life over the past year? That is a big question, but the main thing, I’d say, is a sense of direction. I remember that, the evening before my ceremony, my teacher Richard and I had a one-on-one chat where he pointed to his rakusu—the small, bib-like garment that one receives upon becoming ordained—and said, “This gave my life a sense of direction. Before that, it didn’t have any.”

That seemed odd to me. After all, Richard came to meditation and Zen in his late forties; he already had a family and a successful career in academia. But I guess that is the point. You can go through life seemingly doing the right things—career, family, stability—and still long for something deeper. More meaningful. Or you can lead a free-spirited, untethered lifestyle—as I have done to some extent—and also long for something deeper and more meaningful. Sooner or later, life has a way of teaching you that freedom does not mean doing what you want or pretending that you are your own master—as I pretended for a while.

Here is a quote from Richard’s book, No Fear Zen, that explains this tension:

People who think they are their own masters—like those who make up their own religion—are usually mastered by their job, their family, their friends, their ambition, their addictions, their regrets, their desires, or their illusion that they are their own master. They always have that lack, that desire, the very lack and desire that dissipate during zazen [meditation] and through Zen practice. Devoting yourself to your master, you never need to bow to anyone or anything ever again.

Okumura, a Zen teacher in Indiana who also comes from the Kodo Sawaki lineage, says that living by vow—living in accordance with the Buddha’s teachings—starts with recognizing that we are deluded. From there, we can turn toward the practice of meditation within a sangha (community) in order to “practice with other people, that is to walk together with all living beings.” As I discussed last week, my sangha is not just the people that I meditate with. It encompasses everyone in my life; in a broader sense, it encompasses everyone on the planet. We all walk together.

When Richard pointed to his rakusu and said, “This gave my life a sense of direction,” he happened to be wearing my rakusu—the one that I was going to receive during the ceremony the following morning. He said he was wearing mine, rather than his own, because he had forgotten his upstairs. However, it felt fitting that he was wearing a new disciple’s rakusu when he made that statement.

As someone who teaches martial arts and has just barely begun to teach meditation at NOZT, I know that one’s students provide one with a sense of direction. One has to continually grow and deepen one’s own practice in order to have students in the first place—whether in martial arts, meditation, or any discipline. The students follow the teacher, but the teacher also follows the students.

In my understanding, this cycle is created and sustained by the teacher’s vows, which have no beginning and no end. Living in accordance with vows is what it means to live in the stream. I do not know exactly where this stream will take me, but I have faith in it—I have faith in the Way.

Wherever the stream takes me, I am here for it. It has been a heck of a ride so far.

Preston Thomas receives bodhisattva ordination from Abbot Richard Collins on June 22, 2025.

Fiction or Nonfiction?

Teisho, 19 July 2026, Stone Nest Dojo 

Richard Collins, Abbot

I have been working on my memoir about Robert, as you know. I started out with documents that I could find in the archives here in Sewanee and in my memory. Now that I have a first draft, though, I've been going through my journals to fact-check my memory, and to supplement and clarify what I’ve remembered.

I started at the beginning of those journals with my earliest reflections on Zen practice, around 2000. But it was too embarrassing and depressing to revisit my former consciousness, raw. I was pretty messed up in those early years of practice, even more than I recall. Not unlike why many of us first come to Zen. But I couldn’t bear to read about that time, not yet.

So instead of starting at the beginning I skipped about ten years ahead to just before and after my monastic ordination, around 2009-2011. I was applying for jobs as dean and interviewed for the job in California just days after receiving the kesa. My luggage was lost in transit, and I had to interview in street clothes, which was fine: I got the job. The first year was interesting, juggling roles as a dean and a monk. A lot of the reflection in the journal was worrying about what that meant, that split identity, those two identities. I was totally overthinking it all. But that's how we make sense of things, isn’t it, how we often try to deal with change, how we navigate the world — through our thinking brain, even though that doesn’t always do the job.

Sometime in 2011, I noticed that my anxieties started to level out, and the two identities began to integrate. I stopped being in my head so much and just did what had to be done. I was reading Dogen and wrote down this quote: “...there is no buddhadharma outside of everyday life.” That made sense. It helped me with this dean-versus-monk identity. I wasn't really two different people in one body trying to integrate opposing identities, after all.

I found some notes for an intro to Zen at the new Bakersfield sangha about what I wanted to get across. I listed three things to convey: an appreciation for impermanence or mujo, for emptiness or ku, and for imperfection or dukkha. This last one was a surprise. We usually think of dukkha as suffering, or dissatisfaction. But imperfection makes sense. We suffer because life seems to us unsatisfactory. But what makes it unsatisfactory is that we think it’s imperfect, it doesn’t live up to our idea of the way it should be. 

It was interesting to hear my old self giving my present self some fresh — or rather, refreshed — insight. It was like a message in a bottle from a former self of mine.

This idea of imperfection especially strikes me now because the subtitle of my memoir about Robert is: “Portrait of an Imperfect Zen Master.” (Aren’t they all?)

Soon after that, I also made a note of something Deshimaru said about the three stages of becoming a Zen master. First, there is a period of training, everything you learn by practicing with your teacher, reading texts on your own, sitting in zazen, and so on, up until shiho. We sometimes tend to think of shiho as the endpoint, the culmination of our apprenticeship, graduation. I have heard it said that this is when the hard work begins. Training is nothing compared to practice after shiho when you realize you haven’t really learned anything yet. The third stage is the one I found really interesting. Deshimaru says that you don’t become an independent teacher, a master, until your own master dies. He makes a joke of this, saying that doesn’t mean you should wish for him to die!

I saw how my own career as a Zen teacher fit those stages. I started practice and took bodhisattva ordination in 2001. From then until 2016, I took monastic ordination, went through the shuso ceremony to become an assistant teacher, which culminated in my book No Fear Zen in 2015 and shiho in 2016. The second stage, the hard work, began when I moved into the Temple and took care of Robert for the next five years until 2021 when he died.

Then began the really hard work of being a truly independent teacher, when things, as they say, got real. No more deferring the responsibilities by relying on the teacher or the teachings. As the great 12th-century Chinese Chan Master, a laywomen, Miaodao said: “You suddenly find that you are a teacher; at that time you have to throw away the teachings and teach.”

One more entry from my journal. My daughter Izzy, who was nine at the time, was attending a very conservative Lutheran school where she was bombarded with hellfire and the Bible. I tried to counteract the propaganda with discussions on the way to and from school. They were telling her all kinds of things that she knew weren’t right because she had a scientific mind even then.

So I said you need to take the Bible just like any other book. And she, without skipping a beat, asked: “fiction or nonfiction?”

The perfect answer. Here she became my teacher, not for the first or last time. She was the master and I the disciple.

This brings me back to my journals. Fiction or nonfiction? I am using them to check facts, but they are actually a mixture of fiction and nonfiction. They never tell me the way things really were. Only my fantasies, my anxieties, lots of anxieties! Fictional and nonfictional. All that stuff was all up in my head. Little successes blown out of proportion, little failures blown out of proportion. Ambitions, regrets, mind stuff, all that mental activity we get caught up in by overthinking instead of thinking not-thinking.

Fiction or nonfiction? Both. Because what is a book? A book is just an exploration of our sense of reality. Like any other book, my journals are an expression of my sense of reality at the time.

I know some of you are thinking of bodhisattva or monastic ordination, so I wanted to let you know what was on my mind because when we consider ordination, sometimes we think too much. Even the night before the ceremony, I remember hoping I wouldn’t make a mistake, wondering what my dharma name was going to be! All these egotistical thoughts. Even doubting whether ordination was right for me. Was I making a mistake?

This mental sparring with yourself doesn’t stop after ordination. Part of my embarrassment was reading how even after I became a monk I obsessed about the very things people say when they leave the practice or get cold feet about ordination. I didn’t like the taste of genmai, I didn’t see the point in all the rituals, why are we chanting in Japanese? All of which shocks me now because I thought I was always pretty down with all that.

But then, the year after monastic ordination, all that doubt, all that wavering, mental slicing and dicing, seemed to get sorted out. After ten years of practice it started not just to make sense up here in the brain but to make sense down here in the hara, and here in the heart-mind, the shin, which is our center and the center of our practice. This heart-mind-felt certainty is sometimes called faith. (I don’t like that word, too much religious baggage, just like with “master-disciple” — even so, when I say teacher, you can assume I also mean master; when I say student, you can assume I mean disciple.) Rather than faith, trust may be a better word. Or confidence in giving yourself over, abandoning yourself to destiny. If you don’t feel destined for the practice, it probably isn’t right for you. But one thing is certain: overthinking undermines confidence, trust, faith.

We should definitely quiz our parents, criticize our teachers, question the Bible, interrogate ourselves, and so forth. That’s what our thinking brains are for. But there are aspects of our existence that can’t be thought through with reason or logic, deduction or induction.

Sitting is not the time or place for questioning with the brain. In zazen we just are. That is an important distinction, but it’s very difficult to get there. Even in zazen when we are “just sitting,” just being can be difficult because we are thinking about the pain in our knees, the temperature in the dojo, what we’re having for lunch, all kinds of idiotic trivia. How’s my posture? Am I thinking too much, too little? Am I fantasizing? Am I romanticizing? All the stuff that goes through and then out of your constantly thinking brain.

But then there are those moments of clarity. There are moments of gratitude. There is just being there, as though you are just sitting there, which is the truth of the matter. I’m just sitting here, how wonderful! And that’s enough. And everything is cool. For a minute, before you go back to worrying again. But it is important to remember those moments of insight when everything was cool just as it is. At those moments there is no imperfection, no suffering, no dukkha.

Life is going to present itself as imperfect to us most of the time. These moments of perfection may feel like satori (or epiphanies, or some other inadequate word, so let’s not call them that). Those moments are not special, they are just us getting back to our natural state. Not fiction, not nonfiction. Just the book we are writing with our life.

Zen Is Realism

Richard Collins, Abbot
Stone Nest
5 July 2026

If I was pressed to say there is one single goal in Zen practice, it is the goal of no goal. Going through life with the goal of no goal, we are able to see things as they really are: and that is the single goal. Zen is realism.

That is why it is important not to romanticize Zen. Or rather, I should say, we often come to Zen with romantic notions of exploring exotic and esoteric appearances of Zen. After about a year, though, we begin to realize that there is nothing exotic or esoteric about Zen at all. There is, as they say, nothing special here.

The harder they come, the harder they fall. The more romantic our notions about Zen when we arrive, the more disillusioned we may become. That is significant, because a disillusioned romantic does not become a realist, not at first. They become a cynic. And it takes a lot of rehabilitation to grow out of cynicism and into realism.

People often leave Zen practice after about a year, or a minute. There are many reasons, of course. But it is often the case that the honeymoon is over after a year, like in marriage, and then the real work begins.

Those who drop the practice give all kinds of excuses, some of them quite valid: the practice is too foreign, we chant in Japanese; the practice is phallocentric, there are not enough women in the sangha; we don’t emphasize social engagement enough; we don’t emphasize enlightenment enough; we emphasize samu, work practice, too much; the robes and rituals make them uncomfortable, too reminiscent of whatever religion they came from; and so on.

But the real reason is that our brand of Zen did not live up to their hype, their expectations, their romanticized expectations that there would be some fireworks in the form of satori, some revelation in the dark night of zazen that would not dissipate in the light of every day. Kodo Sawaki was fond of saying that satori was like a thief breaking into an empty house. There is nothing to steal. But it is a wonderful place for us thieves to do zazen.

Living the goal of no goal does not mean you don’t accomplish anything. In fact, you accomplish more, and what you accomplish is more satisfying and more important because your effort comes more naturally, spontaneously, automatically and your attainments are not to be judged by others, or by your own attainments, but by their contribution to the four bodhisattva goals: saving all beings, dropping all illusions, opening all reality gates, and practicing like a buddha. At least that has been true for me, and that is all I can attest to. You will find your path, your own accomplishments.

Like a Fish, Like a Fool

Richard Collins, Abbot
Stone Nest Dojo
28 June 2026

Today I want to talk about the han. This is the neglected stepchild of the instruments. It is the first one we learn how to play, even though very few of us play it very well. It is not given the attention that it deserves.

The han is what calls us to enter the dojo. But it is not just a bell like the school bells that told it was time to get to class, or to get out of class. If that’s all it means to you, try to give it a little more respect.

Some temples have inscriptions on the han, in English or kanji, that spell out what its sound means. Ours never has. Its meaning has always been implied in the sound of wood mallet on wood plank.

For a long time I have thought about adding an inscription to the han here at Stone Nest. But I have never really felt that it was time or that I had come up with the right message.

I knew that it should not be in English, as some temples have it. We don’t chant the Hannya Shingyo in English, so why should the han speak English?

I knew that the inscription on the han at, for example, Tassajara was not right for us. Theirs reads something like this: “Wake Up, Life is transient, Swiftly Passing, Be Aware, The great matter, Don't waste time.”

I have almost finished the first draft of my book on Robert’s life, and I was going to call the preface, which calls us to enter the book, “The Great Matter.” But I didn’t really like that; it sounded too pompous, too pious. Not at all a fitting way to introduce the story of Robert’s life.

It’s a good teaching, this “Wake up, don’t waste time.” But, like the head monk’s verse in the Platform Sutra of Hui-neng, it doesn’t go far enough. At least it doesn’t express what the han calls us to do in our dojo.

This morning I was revising that preface, and I remembered a much more fitting inscription for the han for us, our practice, and for Robert’s life. So this morning, I decided not to waste any more time. (My calligraphy isn’t that great anyway, but I am getting older and my hands are beginning to shake.) 

I got to the dojo early and inscribed two kanji on our han: GYO 魚 for FISH and GU 愚 for FOOL. These two symbols come from the last line of another traditional inscription — 如魚如愚 (nyo gyo nyo gu) — that goes like this:

Completely freed from yes and no;
great emptiness charged within;
no questions, no answers;
like a fish, like a fool.

This is perfect for our han, for our lineage, and for the writing of Robert’s life. Now the opening chapter has a new title: “Like a Fish, Like a Fool.” And the closing lines of the opening chapter of Robert’s life story read:

This is how we approach the Great Matter. It is in this spirit — without choosing, without judgment, without goals — that I begin to tell the story of the life and death of my imperfect Zen master.

Cleaning Out One's Room

Preston Thomas
(Originally Published
on Substack on 31 May, 2026)

"The more you have, the more you have to lose." –Bruce Lee

I want to revisit an idea that I touched on briefly in the past: the value of subtraction in one’s life—that is, the deeper gain that comes from loss. When I say “loss,” I mean the intentional loss of junk or baggage, whether it is in one’s room or in one’s mind.

I am writing from the perspective of someone who has exhibited mild hoarding tendencies. My family, like many families, has hoarded and passed down photos, trinkets, and miscellaneous junk—all in the vain hope of trying to achieve some sort of emotional security or continuity. The desire to achieve this security or continuity is understandable, but it is like trying to hold onto water.

Here is a quote by Shunryu Suzuki that I have cited before:

You should have a general house cleaning of your mind. You must take everything out of your room and clean it thoroughly. If it is necessary, you may bring everything back in again. You may want many things, so one by one you can bring them back. But if they are not necessary, there is no need to keep them…

Before you put something in your room, it is necessary for you to take out something. If you do not, your room will become crowded with old, useless junk.

This teaching seems to jive with what I have heard directly from my Zen teacher, Richard Collins, who describes Zen meditation as a “practice of loss.” He recently gave a two-part talk on the “tyranny of things” (the notion that our things can own us more than we own them, especially when we are attached to and identify with them). He said that this teaching applies to both material and immaterial things.

In the latter category, Zen is a prime example. One can build an identity as a “Zen practitioner”—just like one can build an identity around jiu jitsu, martial arts, film, creativity, and all sorts of other immaterial things. Over the years, I crafted an identity as a filmmaker, and in more recent years I integrated jiu jitsu into that public identity.

In terms of material things, I have already acquired quite a few after being in my new home for a few weeks. For instance, I have gone down a rabbit hole of Japanese-style artwork—including lots of cats. I even went out and bought a TV on the same day that my teacher had spoken about the “tyranny of things.” The irony!

I have made an effort to “clean house”—physically and mentally—a few times in recent years. I had to sift through and discard plenty of old stuff when I made a cross-country move in 2024. At the same time, I had to take an accounting of and clear out plenty of mental junk as well, and that process is ongoing.

When I try to clean out my mind, I often find more stuff to fill it up with. About a year ago, I was consuming podcasts, audiobooks, and articles focused on productivity and self-improvement. Think Andrew Huberman, James Clear, and Ryan Holiday. This sort of content can be beneficial—I have echoed or directly quoted it in Zen Jitsu.

However, I realized at a certain point that I was over-consuming this type of material—I was leaning too heavily on a search for external answers until I finally realized that I needed to search inwardly.

Around this time, I got back into formal Zen practice and met my teacher Richard, who spoke about the “practice of loss.” That phrase resonated with me instantly; it spoke to my desire to take stock of and let go of my accumulated physical and mental junk. In my search for external answers, I had often just added to the mental junk pile.

On the other hand, the writings of Charlotte Joko Beck and Pema Chödrön had helped me realize just how much I needed to “let go” and release some of that junk—a process that begins with patience and compassion toward oneself.

As I have written about in past articles, I have slowly come to realize that letting go means more than just throwing stuff out. You can’t just make it all disappear. In fact, when it comes to the baggage of the mind, you have to observe and work with all of it. This does not mean to ruminate or chase after one’s thoughts; it does mean to dispassionately observe the coming and going of thoughts as one would observe passing clouds on a cloudy day.

When you can sit still and observe yourself in a non-grasping, nonjudgmental way, then you can slowly begin to observe the mental clouds with detachment and perhaps even curiosity. I have made the mistake of wanting to transform my mind into a perfectly clear, unblemished sky—free from anxieties, doubts, or uncertainties. However, that is not how the human mind works—it is never a clear blue sky for too long. Freedom lies in being able to gracefully shift with the mind’s weather.

Circling back to the Suzuki quote, after a period of trying to “clean house” physically and mentally, I have realized that it is okay to bring some things back in. I can bring back some of the podcasts, for instance, as long as they bring me joy and meaning. I can admire the Zen cat paintings that I bought online. I can even have fun watching stuff on my new TV, after a year of not watching any TV at all. (Lately, I am enjoying the neo-noir camp of Tokyo Vice on HBO Max.)

In the past, I have sometimes gotten so deep into a passion—whether it was filmmaking, jiu jitsu, or meditation—that I lived a quasi-monk lifestyle and sequestered myself. Now, however, is the time to go out into the world and enjoy it; as we say in my Zen lineage, the whole world is the field of our practice. After all, we are lay people—not monastics or mountain dwellers.

In New Orleans, and especially in the neighborhood that I live in, the world is at my doorstep. Within a short distance from my home, one can find the rumble of St. Charles Avenue (with its centuries-old streetcar), the hubbub of Magazine Street, the debauchery of the French Quarter, or the lovely greenery of Audubon Park.

Cleaning out my room—physically and mentally—has been and continues to be a valuable, necessary exercise. That being said, I am ready to bring back or even add a few things. If the whole world is the field of our practice, I am ready to play the field, have fun, and take life seriously without taking myself too seriously.

As my Zen teacher Richard recently put it to me: “enjoy and lighten the Way.”

Note: This post was originally published on Zen Jitsu, Preston’s Substack. You can read more posts and subscribe here.

The Tyranny of Intangible Things

Richard Collins, Abbot

(Kusen: Tuesday, 24 May 2026, New Orleans Zen Temple)

On Sunday, I talked about the tyranny of things, how things possess us far more than we possess things. But there’s also the tyranny of intangible things.

In No Fear Zen, I wrote about the error of talking about “my” practice, “my” zazen. As though we somehow own the practice. When we speak in this way, though, we don’t own the practice, the practice owns us.

Ego, as you know, in Latin simply means self (“I” or “me”). It is my sense of identity. It is a useful term of reference, a pointer, to something that is intangible. Like the “selfless soul” of the Kabbalah beneath the layers of our tangible self, or masks, our personae.

But when the ego gets reified, when it turns into a thing, brittle and defined, it becomes a burden and a hindrance. A circumscribed thing, a trapped thing, a caged thing. No longer free. Zazen lets us see the insubstantiality of this brittle mask we have created, the ego.

Our identity. Think about your ID, your identity card. This is a thing created by the state. It defines you and is created so as to limit you. Your drivers license, which says what you can and can’t do, whether you can buy liquor, for instance. Or your passport, which tells you where you can go, who can arrest you.

But the true self has no height or weight, no eye color, no hair color. No home address. It cannot be pictured. It resides at no address on any street or in any state or in any country. This is the self of zazen, the self of true freedom.

Yet when we come to zazen, our ego is still shameless. It is attached to doing things right. We worry about whether we play the instruments correctly, or lead the ceremony incorrectly. Egotism comes in many forms. Modesty is just as egotistical as arrogance or pride. We are still worried about how we will appear to others or to ourselves. When we practice selflessly, we don’t worry about such things. We just show up, ready to do what needs to be done.

On Sunday, I also talked about how we misinterpret discomfort as pain. We talk about “my” pain. This is no different than being owned by our possessions. We get owned by our interpretation of our perception. This is not freedom.

So whenever we are using those terms my, me, mine — my work, my love, my trauma — we need to try to deconstruct that a little bit. All of these are illusions that we need to dismantle. Or if that sounds too intentional, we need to allow them to fall into disuse. Beautiful illusions sometimes, ones that we like to cling to. But also painful illusions sometimes, ones that we want to escape. This is where our suffering comes from. The more we can let go of our own importance, concentrate on the well-being of others, the more we reduce not only the suffering of those around us, but also our own suffering.

And in this way our real purpose gets clarified. It’s not easy. But you wouldn’t be here if you were looking for something easy. It doesn't happen quickly. You probably remember the dedication from Daichi Zenji in the ordination ceremony. About how a horse doesn't show its strength on a short ride, but on the long journey. Similarly, people around us show their worth not in a few moments of time, but over the long haul. Just remember that everything passes. This is all momentary. It's up to you to decide what's important. What is it? What needs to be done — and what doesn't? Your answer will determine your freedom and your suffering. Hopefully you will decide in favor of something that is not just for your own indulgence.